U.S.A. POLITICS: Unchecked Senate filibuster equals doom for electoral reform – opinion


The 14th Amendment to the Constitution guarantees universal adult suffrage but it also allows disenfranchisement for committing a crime. Southern states seized on that loophole post-Reconstruction to round up African Americans, charge them with bogus crimes, inflict punishment by public whipping and take away their votes, as Pema Levy noted in Mother Jones.

“Freed from federal oversight after Reconstruction, most Southern states by the 1900s had rewritten their constitutions to deny Black people the vote through nominally race-blind provisions, including expanded criminal disenfranchisement,” Levy reported. “These measures, alongside poll taxes, literacy tests, grandfather clauses, fraud, registration restrictions, and vigilante violence, were part of the toolkit used by white supremacists to maintain a system of racial subordination.”    

Such disenfranchisement was not just a Southern strategy, Levy said, because it eventually became law in more than 80 percent of states. But “the South became its epicenter after Reconstruction, continuing into the age of mass incarceration.”

It was not until the 1960s that African Americans’ right to vote was entrenched in law under the Voting Rights Act of 1965. But the Supreme Court ruled in 1974 that the “or other crime” constitutional provision empowered states to disenfranchise ex-offenders permanently.

Thirty-nine years later, the Court invalidated a provision in the Voting Rights Act requiring nine states to obtain federal pre-clearance for any proposed electoral changes. They had been deemed to have a history of racially biased voter discrimination but were now free to discriminate.

Several states, both Democrats and Republicans, quickly started drawing up partisan voting boundaries, except that Republicans have been doing so to adversely impact African Americans. The Supreme Court declined in 2019 to intervene.

The districts are redrawn after the Census every 10 years and, with the 2020 counting almost over, states will establish new boundaries for the 2022 mid-term election. This is very significant because of yet another Supreme Court ruling, in 2010, banning limits on corporate (and unions) campaign donations, making corporations citizens.

That “Citizens United” ruling has allowed billionaires, most of them Republican Party funders, to buy elections, vastly out-spending Democratic backers. The Republicans won the House in 2012 and created insurmountable roadblocks to President Barack Obama’s progressive agenda, Jane Mayer reported in her book “Dark Money.”

Currently, 43 states are considering at least 250 voting bills, with those in the South intended to maximize voter suppression, the Brennan Center for Justice reported, although voting fraud was, as usual, just nominal when some 155 million Americans voted in November. In Republican states, the bills “are likely to disproportionately affect those in cities and Black voters, in particular, who overwhelmingly vote Democratic,” The Washington Post reported.

Florida, notorious for voter suppression and disenfranchisement, is among those states and is planning action affecting applications for mail-in ballots and for counting them, The Miami Herald reported. “We want everyone to vote but we don’t want anyone to cheat,” Governor Ron DeSantis claimed — after boasting, following the 2020 election, “We did it right.”

Democrats have responded with the For The People Act, which the House approved on March 3. Senate passage will need the support of at least 10 Republicans to stop a filibuster. The $1.9 trillion American Rescue Plan was passed through a parliamentary procedure known as reconciliation because it is a budgetary measure, which the election reform bill is not.

President Joe Biden can expect total opposition – as happened with even the very popular American Rescue Plan. President Barack Obama faced such resistance for his most ambitious proposals, including particularly the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) health insurance reform bill and curbing global warming and economic inequality.

Obamacare barely passed but other Obama initiatives faced such strong opposition that they were almost unrecognizably diluted. Now, as then, the wealthiest Americans will spare no expenses to stymie Biden, who was Obama’s vice president. They will not yield in their single-minded obsession: safeguarding and expanding their fortunes. Indeed, so greedy are the monied class that, as Mayer pointed out, an heiress to a fashion fortune tried to claim her ex-husband as a dependent to reduce her taxes. A judge informed her that she could not claim her former husband as her son.

None of the new president’s initiatives is as important as the For The People Act because, without electoral reform, systemic inequality cannot be addressed meaningfully. The Democrats can avoid Republican intransigence by scrapping the filibuster using Vice President Kamala Harris for a 51-vote simple majority. But Biden and a few Senators are still hesitant.

If they still believe that at least some Republicans will support the electoral reform and Biden’s agenda generally, thus avoiding the need to abolish the filibuster, they are wrong. They should remember that Republicans overwhelmingly refused to convict Trump of inciting insurrection, despite graphic television evidence. Most refused to certify Biden’s election victory. They refused to support the American Rescue Plan. They refused to allow a hearing on Merrick Garland’s nomination to the Supreme Court but speedily confirmed three Trump nominees. They refused to allow debate on Obama’s federal judicial nominees but confirmed more than 200 from Trump. They refused to allow debate on more than 200 House bills.

Bipartisanship will not come and, if the filibuster remains intact, Biden will have to mark time until the mid-terms in 2022, hoping that he can win a Senate super-majority — which will not happen. The reconciliation option can be used only once more this year, probably for a reported $2 trillion infrastructure program, which will be budget-oriented – if Democrats remain united.

The president must read “Dark Money,” if he has not already done so, as should senior aides and party operatives. It is a sure guide to what is ahead for them.

Mohamed Hamaludin is a Guyana-born journalist who worked for several years at The Guyana Chronicle in the 1970s and on publications in the Cayman Islands and Turks and Caicos Islands before emigrating in 1984 to the United States, where he worked at The Miami Times, the Miami Herald and the South Florida Times.  Though now retired, he writes a commentary every week or two for The South Florida Times (sfltimes.com) in which the above column first appeared. He may be reached at hamal1942@gmail.com.

Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.


  • kamtanblog  On 03/19/2021 at 3:48 am

    Really !

    Politricks post mortem/autopsy


  • brandli62  On 03/19/2021 at 8:01 am

    The filibuster needs to go! It’s an undemocratic instrument as a minority can block the will of the majority. Furthermore, the senate is already heavy overweighted with representatives from rural and conservative states. Each state sends two senators irrespective of its population.

    Wyoming (580’000 inhabitants), North Dakota (760’000) and South Dakota (880’000) send collectively six senators to Washington, whereas California with a population close to 40 million sends 2 only. Given these facts, it does not seem to me that rural minorities are at a disadvantage in the senate.

  • Francis Quamina Farrier  On 03/20/2021 at 11:10 am

    Dear Kamtanblog and brandli62; Greetings. Please permit me to be slightly rude. From the way so many of our fellow Guyanese residing in the USA speak of the country of their birth, The Cooperative of Guyana, one would be of view that ONLY Guyana has political and social problems – and certainly not the USA. Of course, January 6, 2021, proves otherwise. I make this rude comment because I am asking those Guyanese LOUD Mouths to just ease-up on their negative rhetoric about the country where their navel strings are buried. YES, Guyana has tons of problems, but I’ve learnt that one should not curse the dark, rather LIGHT A CANDLE. God Bless Guyana.

    • brandli62  On 03/20/2021 at 11:47 am

      Greetings returned, Francis! First, my comment above refers to US politics and has no connection to Guyana. Secondly, if you check my comments to other blog posts, I speak out but I always try to respectful. As a matter of fact, I have been condemning racial slurs on Guyanese Online in the past and I am determined to be constructive. I am glad to share my views based on living in the US and different European countries, now residing in Switzerland and Germany, over the last forty years. I am however fully aware that as an expat I can express my opinion but it is the Guyanese living in Guyana that will have the final say on their destiny. In future, if you feel that a specific comment of mine is disrespectful or patronising, please reply to the specific comment and then I can reassess the issue. Anyway, thanks for expressing your views, even if we may disagree.

      Finally, I would like to take the opportunity to let you know that I treasure your frequent contributions, many autobiographical and with a rich historical perspective! Please keep them coming!

    • Brother Man  On 03/20/2021 at 4:34 pm

      Dear Francis: your point is well taken. All empires rise and fall. No one needs to be reminded of this reality. We are witnessing the unpleasant fall of the American Empire. America has its priorities all screwed up. They spend more on the military when their roadways, bridges, and cities are falling apart.

      You are right, we have our problems but so too does everyone else.

      Brother Man

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: