Kamala Harris Is a Milestone for America; Good for Biden and Comforting for Jews – opinion

Harris married into the tribe and is backed by some significant Jewish donors. But Netanyahu and his friend in the White House, who hoped to have a field day with a more progressive candidate, are a different story 

Chemi Shalev | Haaretz – Analysis

Joe Biden’s decision to appoint California Senator Kamala Harris as his running mate was logical, reasonable, calculated and widely expected. Biden thought, checked, discussed, polled, interviewed, consulted, deliberated, changed his mind and reconsidered before making his final decision. After four years of Donald Trump’s chronic chaos and caprice, Biden’s patient and methodical decision-making process carries its own message: THIS, HE REMINDED AMERICANS, IS THE WAY SERIOUS PRESIDENTS ARE SUPPOSED TO BEHAVE.           

Of all the potential candidates who qualified for consideration, Harris provides the best answers to Biden’s most pressing political needs, with the added bonus of ensuring his place in history.  If only by virtue of appointing the first woman of color to the national ticket of either big party, Biden’s name will be forever inscribed as a civil rights trailblazer and equality pioneer.

Harris’ promotion enthralled Biden’s Democratic base. It was greeted with grudging satisfaction throughout other wings of the party as well. Much to their own surprise, liberal types on social media were effusive in expressing relief, joy, and even a kind of national pride, emotions they thought long gone after four years of Trump in the White House.

Unlike other, younger presidential candidates, Biden could not allow himself to make do with a pale run-of-the-mill running mate who brings a geographical dowry but never outshines the boss. The lingering doubts about his age compelled Biden to appoint a politician talented and experienced enough, not only to stand by his side but also to replace him, if it ever becomes necessary.

Harris, who gained national recognition and support in the course of her short and volatile primary run earlier this year, was seen by many Democrats as the most presidential of Biden’s VP choices by far.

Harris’ appointment also marks Biden’s strategic political decision about the tone and nature of his campaign and where he wants to run it from: THE CENTER, where he feels most comfortable.

Harris’ appointment reassured her many admirers in Biden’s own centrist/establishment base and provided a staging ground for both her and Biden to try and lure wavering Republicans and independent voters who have had it with Trump but need one more push before crossing to the other side. 

Biden came to the conclusion that the benefits of appointing a centrist VP candidate who can rebuff GOP efforts to tar Democrats as radicals far outweigh the potential harm of disappointing the radicals themselves.

Biden assumes, perhaps mistakenly, that their venomous dislike of Trump will provide sufficient fuel to drive progressives to the polls even if they’re not happy with Harris or Biden or even both. 

By appointing Harris, Biden checked all the appropriate boxes of identity politics and picked a running mate who seems to be his polar opposite: Harris is black, relatively young at 55, quick-minded and sharp tongued and plays West Coast to Biden’s East Coast to boot. To his great credit and Trump’s total bafflement, Biden even managed to rise above Harris’ infamous evisceration of his past collaboration with segregationist senators during the televised primary debates. Perhaps he appreciates the spunk.


Thinly veiled racism directed at America’s first black female vice presidential candidate may enthuse Trump’s white supremacist base but it will also galvanize angry Democrats as well as fair-minded Republicans, INSOFAR AS THEY STILL EXIST.  

HARRIS’ MIXED ETHNICITIES DEFY CATEGORIZATION IN ANY CASE. Her father is Jamaican and her mother Indian-Tamil. Although she is dark skinned, African-Americans don’t view her completely as one of their own. For potential Republican defectors who have yet to shed their prejudices, Harris’ story can be viewed through the prism of immigrant daughter rising to top, as prescribed in the American Dream. Americans whose origins are in JAMAICA or INDIA, for their part, are sure to flock to the polls.  

MOST OF THE JEWS, NEEDLESS TO SAY, ARE KVELLING AS WELL. The majority of American Jews who vote for the Democrats identify with the party establishment as well as with Biden and Harris’ centrist positions.

Jews were relieved to learn that Biden had not opted to balance out his ticket with a progressive vice-presidential pick. WITH HARRIS, THE JEWS WILL FEEL AT HOME: She married into the tribe, socializes in circles in which Jews feel comfortable and is backed by several well-known and well-trusted Jewish donors. Like Biden, Harris is intimately familiar with Jewish shtick and Yiddishkeit, enough to not only persuade Jews to come out and vote but to capture their hearts as well.

By the same token, Harris’ appointment will come as an even greater relief to AIPAC and other pro-Israeli groups, who have been crying gevalt over the supposedly unstoppable rise of the radicals, who are considered anti-Israel almost by definition.

Like Biden, Harris is seen as a solid Democratic supporter of Israel, which won’t make any difference to the GOP’s Jewish right, which is already savaging her non-existent record of acting against the Jewish state. 

Benjamin Netanyahu will hardly be reassured, either, given that he no longer takes the trouble to differentiate between valid criticism of Israeli policies or even him personally and opposition to the country’s very existence.

Netanyahu, in fact, may be disappointed, along with his friend in the White House: Both could have had a field day with a more progressive VP pick who could be described as a Hamas-supporting, Israel-hating anti-Semite.

Netanyahu’s critics, meanwhile, are already hoarding up on popcorn in anticipation of the first rhetorical duel between the prime minister and Harris, who has criticized him in the past. Netanyahu’s opponents can’t wait for Harris to lash out at him with her famously sharp and deadly tongue. 

This is doubly true of Trump’s opponents, who were apprehensive about Biden’s ability to match the president’s penchant for punchy put-downs and are overjoyed at the deployment of Harris’ rapid-fire rhetoric on the battlefield. Spare a thought, however, for Trump’s own Vice President, Mike Pence. The appointment of the charismatic Harris has already focused a sad spotlight on Pence’s slavish blandness, and now he can look forward to her destroying and humiliating him in their single scheduled debate in early October.

Small wonder that some of Trump’s advisers are urging him to dump Pence and to replace him with the far more popular and telegenic former UN Ambassador Nikki Haley, whose parents also immigrated from India. Now that would be a fight for the ages, a blockbuster battle between two formidable politicians whose personal stories embody the American Dream.

A Harris-Haley showdown would showcase just how far women have come in America, though it could also precipitate widespread uncontrollable rioting across an Indian subcontinent split between the warring sides.  

Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.


  • brandli62  On 08/13/2020 at 2:52 am

    Food for thought:
    Kamala Harris, the daughter of an Indian mother and a black Jamaican father, could be an example for Guyana. Wouldn’t more mixed-race couples and their children help to close the divisions between the two dominant ethnic groups in Guyana? At some point everybody will have a mixed race heritage and be proud of it. This will also take race out of the equation in general elections.

    • Linda  On 08/13/2020 at 10:35 am

      This is already on its way to becoming a reality and will be a great advancement in changing the face of the political landscape.

      • brandli62  On 08/13/2020 at 11:43 am

        Is this indeed the case? Do the demographics support this notion?

      • Brother Man  On 08/13/2020 at 12:58 pm

        We is one people united!

        Don’t let the politicians tell you otherwise.

  • Clyde Duncan  On 08/13/2020 at 9:33 pm

    I Used to be Critical of Kamala. Now I Am Going to Defend Her at Every Turn

    Shanita Hubbard | The Guardian UK

    The historic announcement of Kamala Harris as Joe Biden’s VP pick is another reminder that multiple things can be true at the same time. Harris is undeniably brilliant, has recently introduced bills that would specifically improve the quality of life for Black Americans, and by all accounts she is superior in every way imaginable to the current president.

    In fact, adding her to the ticket has made me far more enthusiastic about this race than I was even days before the announcement.

    Throughout this campaign, Biden has said things that made me question his understanding of the Black community, let alone his commitment to fight against social inequality. And yet, here we are, squarely seated in that space where many truths exist at once. Does Biden give me pause? Oh, absolutely.

    Do I believe he will be a better leader than Trump? Without a shadow of a doubt.

    But is that the bar?

    Are millions of Americans expected to capitulate to such a defeating standard from our future leaders?

    That question lingered in the air of every political conversation I had with my peers over the past few months. Yet with the announcement that caught very few of us by surprise, a jolt of excitement was inserted back into this election.

    Rightfully so.

    While lots of articles will focus on the historical weight of this moment, we cannot ignore that Harris isn’t just representation. She is a viable force who has the skills to be the vice-president of the United States. This will undoubtedly bring out more support for the ticket. However, here we are again, still parked at that intersection and carefully holding space for multiple facts to exist at the same time.

    What does this selection mean for those of us who had fair criticism of Harris when she was running for president?

    How do we even express this concern knowing that our policy-based questions could be conflated with the sea of misogynoir she will surely face?

    If Hillary Clinton faced an insane amount of hatred and sexism, what does this mean for Harris in a country where we are still fighting to declare that Black lives actually matter?

    I was one of the people who publicly expressed concern about Harris during her presidential campaign. A few key things have changed since then. She impressed me with her actions, and I’m hoping that this apparent pivot is what voters can expect of her. Yet more importantly than her recent actions, my politics have changed.

    While I wholeheartedly still believe in the power of voting, I’m now more committed to what I call zoning in. I’m narrowing the focus of my political efforts and treating voting as simply one tool for change. This change in my political view has caused me to emotionally divest more from a failing two-party system that often places its most vulnerable citizens in the position of choosing between how slowly we want to be metaphorically killed. This is my truth.

    Yet it is also true that I intend to vote for the Biden and Harris ticket because I believe they present a better chance at improving the lives of marginalized communities than this current administration.

    I will do this while increasing my efforts to organize on a local level and use every weapon at my disposal to fight for a path for justice that isn’t predicated on me choosing between the “lesser of two evils”.

    Simultaneously, while Harris starts to fight like hell to re-energize the Democratic base, I’ll use my position as a writer to push back on unfair attacks on her that are simply misogynoir masked as criticism.


    For those currently expressing concern, I challenge you to sit with it a minute and consider if this concern was ever present for any of the other highly questionable candidates. I invite those with criticism to still express it and demand the best from Harris, but I will challenge them to interrogate the root of their angst. I intend to do the same.

    I am going to stand with Harris and fight against sexist and racist attacks, celebrate with the Black women who are rejoicing in pride, while I simultaneously organize on a local level and strategize ways to help ensure my community gets more than just a false sense of hope from this ticket. All of this can happen at the same time.

  • Clyde Duncan  On 08/14/2020 at 12:18 am

    I read this paragraph – and I laughed out loud:

    “Small wonder that some of Trump’s advisers are urging him to dump Pence and to replace him with the far more popular and telegenic former UN Ambassador Nikki Haley, whose parents also immigrated from India. Now that would be a fight for the ages, a blockbuster battle between two formidable politicians whose personal stories embody the American Dream.”

    Imagine Trump switching horses in the finishing stretch …?!?!!

  • Hector Duncan  On 08/14/2020 at 3:49 am


  • brandli62  On 08/14/2020 at 4:22 am

    The upcoming elections in the US are extremely critical for the future of the USA.

    The Washington Post columnist Max Boot, a former Republican Party member, concludes in a recent article: “We are all suffering from scandal fatigue, but this scandal cannot be ignored: Trump does not want the intelligence community to expose Russian attacks because he is their beneficiary. This is yet another example of how Trump undermines our democracy and subordinates our national security to his personal interests. It is hard to imagine a greater or more dangerous dereliction of duty. If Trump is not held accountable in November, the damage to our institutions may become irreversible.”

    In other words, if Trump is re-elected, US democracy as we know it is over.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s