OPINION: Venezuela’s conflict with Exxon led to US Sanctions – Globovision article

The late president Hugo Chavez

The Venezuelans said that the evidence is quite clear that Exxon is trying to take revenge after their country managed to win all the arbitration cases that were filed against it.

The World Bank’s International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) had overturned Exxon’s US$1.6 B claim for damages in 2017.

Immediately after this ruling, former Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of ExxonMobil, Rex Tillerson, the main player in the lawsuits against Venezuela, was named Foreign Secretary of the US by President Donald Trump.           

A 2017 Reuters article had raised questions as to how Tillerson would treat his enemy.

In fact, Tillerson was in full support of a few recent sanctions imposed against Venezuela by the Trump administration in an attempt to bend the Socialist Government into subjection.

former CEO of ExxonMobil Rex Tillerson

THE BEGINNING OF THE “FALLOUT” BETWEEN EXXON AND VENEZUELA

Ties between these two parties were first severed in 1976 when the then Venezuelan President Carlos Andres Pérez sought to nationalise the oil industry.

But they soon become friends again in the 1990s when Perez decided to launch the so-called “Apertura Petrolera” (“oil opening”).

His initiative was focused on attracting foreign investment to partner with state owned Oil Company, PDVSA, to develop his country’s Orinoco Belt.

ExxonMobil was granted the opportunity to invest in two of the most lucrative blocks in the Orinoco belt, Cerro Negro and La Ceiba.
This time around, ExxonMobil did not waste any time to ensure that a good deal was obtained where it would benefit heavily from its investments.

A contract filled with stability clauses and a frightening provision to force Venezuela to adhere to the sanctity of the contract, was signed.

However, Exxon’s “sweet ride” did not last for a decade. The late Hugo Chavez defeated Perez and became the new leader of Venezuela.

Venezuela’s Lawyer George Kahale

The new president began by updating Venezuela’s 1975 Nationalization Act. This Act granted him the power to establish a new law in 2001 known as the Hydrocarbons Act which included a Sovereignty right rule.

Between the period 2001 and 2006 Chavez led massive campaigns to convince his supporters that they deserve a better life.

He preached that the only way to do so is bring Venezuela’s contract with foreign oil companies in conformity with the country’s laws.

The charismatic leader was able to motivate his supporters that the contract allowed oil companies to cart off the wealth that belongs to the Venezuelan people.

With the support of millions of Venezuelans, Chavez, in 2007 told oil companies that the contract they had with the ex-president Perez was illegal.
He enforced the country’s Nationalization Act of 1975 and the 2001 Hydrogen Carbon Act.

These two Acts would allow PDVSA to become the biggest shareholders in the two blocks that Exxon operated.
With the aid of the Sovereignty right rule Chavez, raised the taxes imposed on the foreign oil companies from 33% to 40%.

ExxonMobil immediately disagreed and continued operations as normal by saying that Venezuela is obligated to adhere to contract sanctity.

This then prompted Chavez to forcefully seize the company’s operations in Cerro Negro and La Ceiba.

Tillerson was the CEO at that time and became enraged. He said that the contract was disregarded and treated as a “proverbial scrap of paper”.
He then moved to initiate three lawsuits claiming more than US$10B in damages.

But Venezuela refused to be beaten into subjection and hired George Kahale as its lawyer. In fact, the lawyer was so confident that he said that Venezuela will not pay a cent in damages.

Venezuela’s defence statement was made public in 2008 by the Venezuelan Embassy in the US.

The statement was captioned, “Fact Sheet: Arbitration between ExxonMobil and Venezuela”, and read, “Venezuela’s intention has been to bring illegal oil projects from the rich Orinoco Oil Belt into its legal framework and thus stop the continued transferring of resources needed for social development from the People of Venezuela to the coffers of large foreign multinational companies”.

“This has been accepted by all oil companies operating in Venezuela, except ExxonMobil”.

Venezuela’s argument was good enough to convince ICSID that law takes precedence over the disputed contract sanctity.
The more than US$10B in damages was reduced significantly in 2014. Venezuela was ordered to pay Exxon only US$1.6B.
This amount was to compensate Exxon because Venezuela had chosen to increase the tax rates, thus breaching the agreement.

But Venezuela did not give up; an appeal was filed on the grounds that the Sovereignty right rule allowed Venezuela the privilege to increase taxes if its citizens demanded.

The evidence produced showed that Chavez had immense support from his supporters in his move to increase Exxon’s taxes.

As a result, the US$1.6B was annulled by the ICSID in 2017.

However, Venezuela has since been pounded with sanctions after sanctions which weakened the country’s economy, plunging it into crisis.

Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.

Comments

  • kamtanblog  On December 23, 2019 at 12:55 am

    Interesting update on the oil crisis in Venezuela. Politricks!
    Fast forward
    Won’t surprise me to read that Mad-Uro
    will be taking legal action against exon-Mobil
    Guyana’s extraction. Today it is possible to
    drill sideways…Iraq was accused of doing so
    by Kuwait one of reasons for war/invasion
    of Kuwait by Sadam before USA/UK invaded
    Iraq to remove Sadam.
    Maduro refugees are already invading its
    neighbours Guyana and Brazil.
    Will USA invade Venezuela?…doubt it !
    We can but speculate on what will happen
    next. Will have to look into
    crystal ball for answers.
    Politricks

  • Trevor  On December 26, 2019 at 3:59 pm

    During the 60s to 80s, When the Europeans started invading Venezuela in droves to buy up the real estate in Caracas (using a higher currency), hundreds of thousands of locals were forced to live in shacks.

    There were concerns that while everyone is treating Haitians, Cubans and Amerindian-Venezuelans as suspect, the real troublemaker is the one from European countries who have an ancestral history of genociding Amerindians in the Americas, and they still continue to promote discrimination and mass murder.

    Hugo Chavez wanted to stop that, the “gringos” and “Yankees” from taking over Venezuela, and he & his supporters paid the ultimate price.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s